Main Menu

How do we work? Either place your order online or call it in, and we go to work.  No part of your order is pre-frozen or made last week, which is not true with so many of our other competitors.

Please send your order to: clare@whimsicalwhisk.com or call (317) 730-6802

1 dz minimum of the same kind of cookie/Flat/brownie

Hardy Cookies: $18/dz  

Awesome Colossal : Our Top Selling Cookie!- An awesome combination of peanut butter, chocolate and oatmeal

Campfire: A rich combination of pecans, coconut, 2 kinds of chocolate

Candied Sweet Potato Cookie : A favorite amongst many locals- Made with freshly baked sweet potatoes, pecans, and finished with a rich maple icing.

Double Chocolate Cherry Chunk: Loaded with chocolate and dried plump cherries.

 Killer Truffle $18/dz This a cross between a truffle and air. Yes air because when devoured at room temp it collapses in your mouth. It is dark chocolate and pecans soaked in a liqueur. The longer they sit the better they are.

Chocolate Stud $30/dz 3 kinds of chocolate and no nuts- Voted Best Brownie Ever! It is incredibly moist, wet and full of chocolate.

Rocky Mountain Brownie $36/dz Moist and incredibly rich. combination of walnuts, 2 kinds of chocolate and marshmallows

Jungle Wild $27/dz Our first layered brownie: pecans, chocolate, and toasted coconut on a chocolate cookie crust

Blackberry Flats $24/dozen Thin layers of pastry filled with blackberry jam, spice, and pecans

Muddy Raspberry Flats $24/dz Thin layers of pastry filled with chocolate and raspberry jam

Apricot Almond Flats $24/dz Thin layers of pastry filled with apricot jam,  almond paste, almonds, and cinnamon sugar

Tea Cookies: $30/ 2 dozen (of the same kind of cookie)

Lemon Drops : Lemon poppy seed wafer filled with lemon cream

Island Wafer Creams: Lime cookie with a key lime cream filling

Lavender: A Lavender shortbread filled with a fresh lemon cream.

Poker Dice: Dice shaped and lightly spice with a port and cream filling

Sugar Ribbons : A sugar cookie exture, rich in vanilla and topped with a coating of vanilla bean sugar

*We accept all major credit cards